Get a quote

Staining vs Sealing a Deck: Which One is Right for You?

If you have a deck, keeping it in good shape is important. Over time, weather, foot traffic, and even sunlight can wear down the wood, making it look old and worn. Two main ways to protect your deck are staining and sealing.

Both options have their own benefits, so let’s break down what each does, the pros and cons, and which might be best for your deck.

Key Takeaways

  • Stain Adds Color and UV Protection, Sealers Focus on Water Resistance
  • Climate Dictates the Best Option
  • Stain Lasts Longer, Sealers Are Easier to Reapply
  • Proper Prep and Maintenance Are Key

What’s the Difference Between Staining and Sealing?

  • Staining: Staining a deck adds color to the wood. It helps enhance the look by highlighting the wood grain while providing a layer of protection against UV rays and moisture.
  • Sealing: Sealing a deck, on the other hand, is more about protection. Sealers are clear or slightly tinted and create a barrier that repels water, helping to prevent rot, mold, and mildew.
In simple terms, stain is about both looks and protection, while sealers focus mostly on protecting the wood.

Pros and Cons of Staining a Deck

  • Pros of Staining
  • Color Options: Stain gives you a range of colors to choose from, so you can match your deck to your home’s style.
  • UV Protection: Stain provides some level of UV protection, keeping the wood from fading and drying out in the sun.
  • Enhances Wood Grain: Stain brings out the natural beauty of the wood grain, adding a richer, more vibrant look.
  • Cons of Staining
  • Maintenance: Stains will eventually wear down and need to be reapplied every couple of years to keep the color looking fresh.
  • Can Be Prone to Peeling: If not applied properly, stain can peel or flake over time, especially in high-traffic areas.

Pros and Cons of Sealing a Deck

  • Pros of Sealing
  • Water Protection: Sealers do a great job at repelling water, so they’re ideal if you live in a rainy area or have a deck near water.
  • Keeps Wood Natural: Sealing doesn’t change the color of the wood much, so it’s a good option if you like the natural look of your deck.
  • Quick Application: Sealers are generally easy to apply and dry quickly, which can make the process simpler.
  • Cons of Sealing
  • Limited UV Protection: Most sealers don’t protect against the sun’s UV rays, so your deck might still fade over time.
  • Less Aesthetic Appeal: Sealers are usually clear or lightly tinted, so they don’t add much to the look of your deck.

Staining vs. Sealing: Which Lasts Longer?

Both stain and sealer need to be reapplied, but how often depends on factors like weather, sun exposure, and foot traffic.
  • Staining: A good-quality stain can last 2-3 years before it needs reapplying. However, in high-sun areas, the color might fade faster.
  • Sealing: Sealers often need to be reapplied annually, especially in areas with heavy rain or extreme weather. They’re usually quicker to apply, though, which can make maintenance easier.
If you’re looking for something low-maintenance, stain might be the better choice since it lasts a bit longer. But if you’re more concerned with water protection, a sealer could be your best bet.

The Best Choice for Different Climates

Your climate plays a big role in deciding whether to stain or seal.
  • Rainy or Humid Climates: In areas with lots of rain or humidity, sealing is crucial to keep water out and prevent issues like rot or mildew.
  • Sunny Climates: If you live somewhere with strong sunlight, a stain with UV protection can help prevent the wood from drying out and cracking.

Many people who live in areas with both lots of rain and sunshine may even choose to use both – staining their deck for color and UV protection, then adding a clear sealer for extra water resistance.

Can You Stain and Seal a Deck?

Yes! You can stain and then seal a deck for the best of both worlds. This option allows you to get the color and UV protection from the stain, plus the water resistance of the sealer. However, make sure you’re using products that work well together – some stains come with built-in sealers, which can make the process simpler and save time.

Choosing the Right Option for Your Deck

Staining and sealing are both great ways to protect and enhance your deck. If you want a specific color and a bit of UV protection, staining might be right for you. If you just need basic water protection, go with a sealer. And if you want both, you can always apply a stain first, then follow with a clear sealer.

If you’re from Pennsylvania and you’re Ready to give your deck some TLC? Contact us at (215) 608-6886 so we can get started.